Section 86a of the German Criminal Code – Allegation of using unconstitutional symbols
Criminal defense in cases involving the use of symbols of unconstitutional and terrorist organizations
Investigations under Section 86a of the German Criminal Code (StGB) often arise from situations that initially appear commonplace or politically motivated to the accused: a symbol on a poster, a slogan at a demonstration, an image on social media, or a print on clothing. What was intended as a provocative statement, political criticism, or an expression of personal opinion can be interpreted by law enforcement authorities as the criminal use of a symbol.
Unlike Section 86 of the German Criminal Code (StGB), Section 86a StGB does not focus on the content of a text or medium, but rather on the external use of certain signs, symbols, or slogans in public spaces. Criminal liability is thus linked less to a propagandistic message than to the impression of identification that a symbol can create in unbiased third parties.
This very focus on visibility and external impact leads to significant problems of demarcation in practice. Whether a symbol is actually perceived as an emblem of an unconstitutional or terrorist organization depends largely on its specific appearance, the situational context, and the recognizability of any distancing. Current case law shows that criminal liability is by no means self-evident, but requires careful case-by-case examination.
Allegations under Section 86a of the German Criminal Code should therefore be legally classified at an early stage in order to avoid hasty conclusions and disproportionate investigative measures.
What does Section 86a of the German Criminal Code regulate?
Section 86a of the German Criminal Code (StGB) criminalizes the use of symbols of certain organizations. Similar to Section 86 of the German Criminal Code, the aim is to protect the free and democratic basic order and public peace.
License plates are recorded:
- unconstitutional organizations (especially National Socialist organizations),
- banned parties or associations,
- terrorist organizations, including those listed on the EU terrorist list.
The offense is not directed against specific political beliefs, but against the public image of such organizations. Their symbols, slogans, and insignia are to be kept out of public spaces.
What are "license plates" within the meaning of Section 86a of the German Criminal Code?
The concept of a symbol is broad and encompasses more than classic symbols like the swastika. According to established case law, it refers to characteristic objects of identification that convey to impartial individuals the impression of a symbol of recognition for the respective organization.
This includes in particular:
- Symbols (e.g. swastika, SS runes),
- Slogans and slogans,
- Flags, badges and patches,
- Image and word combinations,
- acoustic markers (e.g., chanted slogans),
- digital representations such as images, stickers, or emojis.
It is not decisive whether the symbol was historically invented by the organization. It is sufficient that the organization has adopted the word sequence or symbol as its identifying mark.
Typical case scenarios from practice
Social media, messengers and digital content
A significant proportion of proceedings under Section 86a of the German Criminal Code (StGB) now originate in the digital realm. Typical charges include:
- posting or sharing images with symbolic references,
- the use of stickers or memes,
- Profile pictures or usernames with slogans,
- forwarding content in chat groups,
- Commenting on or "liking" problematic content.
Case law clarifies that criminal liability does not automatically follow from the mere existence of a post. The Bavarian Higher Regional Court requires sound findings as to whether content was actually accessible to a larger group of people. If there are no findings regarding the visibility or reach of a Facebook post, the offense of dissemination cannot be established.
BayObLG, Decision of 16.07.2025 – 206 StRR 205/25, BeckRS 2025, 13145.
Demonstrations and assemblies
Another focus is on political assemblies. Investigations often concern:
- chanted slogans,
- Banners and signs,
- Signs affixed to clothing or posters,
- Speeches with a call to action character.
The specific context is crucial here. Administrative courts have repeatedly ruled that restrictions or conditions imposed on public assemblies are only permissible if there is a sound risk assessment. The Bremen Administrative Court ruled that a mere abstract reference to unconstitutional symbols is insufficient; concrete circumstances of the individual case are required, from which an immediate danger can be derived.
VG Bremen, Decision of 15.03.2024, BeckRS 2024, 28784.
Public use and distribution
Section 86a of the German Criminal Code covers both the public use and the dissemination of symbols.
- Public use occurs when the license plate is displayed in a way that is perceptible to a group of people who are not individually defined.
- Distribution requires that the content is actively shared and made accessible to a larger group of people.
The legal system requires a precise determination of the facts. According to the decision of the Bavarian Higher Regional Court (BayObLG), it is insufficient to simply refer to the use of a social media platform. Specific findings are required as to whether the respective post was publicly accessible or made available only to a limited group of people. If this is lacking, a conviction is legally flawed.
Subjective element: Intent is required
Section 86a of the German Criminal Code also requires intent. Accused persons must at least accept that the symbol used is an emblem of a prohibited or terrorist organization.
In practice, this point is often disputed:
- Was the meaning of the symbol known?
- Was the organizational structure identifiable?
- Was it merely a political statement without any intention of identification?
Especially in cases involving ambiguous slogans or image motifs, there are regularly grounds for defense.
Slogans as symbols – current case law
Decisions regarding when linguistic expressions qualify as identifying characteristics within the meaning of Section 86a of the German Criminal Code (StGB) are of particular practical importance.
In a recent ruling, the Berlin Court of Appeal emphasized that slogans may only be classified as symbols of a terrorist organization if it is reliably established that the organization actually uses them as an identity-defining identifier. The mere political use of a slogan is insufficient; a sound assessment is required, possibly with the aid of expert opinions.
KG Berlin, Decision of 27.02.2024 – 3 ORs 5/24, BeckRS 2026, 737.
The Ingolstadt Regional Court also emphasizes that the protective purpose of Section 86a of the German Criminal Code does not encompass every provocative or shocking use of symbols. The decisive factor is whether the symbol, based on its objective appearance, is capable of conveying the impression of identification with the unconstitutional organization.
LG Ingolstadt, Decision of 11.01.2024, BeckRS 2024, 24002.
Social acceptability and freedom of expression
Not every use of a symbol is a criminal offense. Section 86a of the German Criminal Code (StGB) reaches its limit where the use recognizably serves civic education, science, art, reporting, or critical discourse.
However, the legal system sets high standards for such socially acceptable use. A merely subjective distancing is insufficient. The opposition must be clearly and unambiguously recognizable.
Investigative reality and consequences
Proceedings under Section 86a of the German Criminal Code (StGB) often have significant consequences far beyond the criminal proceedings themselves. Unlike many other offenses, the effects of an investigation or conviction are not limited to fines or imprisonment, but extend into other areas of law.
Consequences under weapons law
A conviction – or even a preliminary suspicion relevant to criminal law – can lead to measures under weapons law. Administrative courts consider the use of symbols of unconstitutional organizations to be a significant indication of unreliability under weapons law. The Bavarian Administrative Court of Appeal (VGH Munich) has confirmed that mere doubts about loyalty to the constitution can be sufficient grounds for revoking or not renewing weapons permits.
VGH Munich, Decision of 21.02.2024, BeckRS 2025, 20854.
For those accused, this means that even an ongoing criminal investigation can effectively lead to the loss of firearms entitlements.
Legal and professional consequences
Investigations under Section 86a of the German Criminal Code (StGB) can also have serious consequences in the public sector or in areas closely related to public service. The Higher Administrative Court of Münster has ruled that statements or the use of symbols in private chat groups can be considered disciplinary offenses if they suggest a lack of loyalty to the constitution.
OVG Münster, Judgment of 07.12.2023, BeckRS 2025, 16265.
In practice, depending on the individual case, the following risks may arise:
- disciplinary measures,
- Removal from service,
- Refusal of promotions,
- Termination or non-renewal of employment contracts.
Immigration law consequences
For non-German defendants, investigations or convictions under Section 86a of the German Criminal Code (StGB) can have significant consequences regarding their residency status. Criminal assessments for the use of unconstitutional or terrorist symbols are regularly interpreted by immigration authorities as an indication of a lack of integration or insufficient loyalty to the constitution.
Even a conviction resulting in a fine can – depending on the individual case – be grounds for:
- the revocation or non-renewal of a residence permit,
- a reduction in the validity period of existing residence permits,
- the refusal of a residence permit,
- Ancillary decisions concerning residence rights within the framework of discretionary decisions.
Administrative courts do not focus solely on the severity of the sentence, but also on the nature of the offense. Offenses involving statements related to unconstitutional or terrorist organizations are frequently classified as having a particularly high relevance to integration.
The Administrative Court of Berlin has clarified that criminal investigations and convictions for extremist affiliations may be taken into account in immigration law decisions, even if the criminal proceedings have not yet been concluded with legal force.
VG Berlin, Decision of 19 January 2024, BeckRS 2025, 7044.
Further consequences
In addition to consequences relating to weapons, service and residence law, further side effects may arise, such as:
- Restrictions on safety-relevant activities,
- Problems with naturalization procedures,
- Lasting reputational damage with professional repercussions.
Precisely because these consequences are often automatically linked to criminal assessments, early legal action is crucial. The goal is not only to avoid a criminal conviction, but also to consider potential subsequent decisions in other areas of law from the outset.
Case law shows that even first-instance convictions resulting in short prison sentences or fines can have significant collateral consequences. Further decisions, such as that of the Offenburg District Court, illustrate that while courts must consider personal circumstances when determining sentences, this does not necessarily protect against a severe sanction.
Offenburg District Court, Judgment of 06.06.2023, BeckRS 2024, 42283.
Defense strategies under Section 86a of the German Criminal Code
A successful defense regularly addresses several points:
- precise context analysis,
- Examination of the license plate characteristics,
- Attack on publicity and dissemination,
- Verification of intent,
- Appealing to social adequacy and freedom of expression,
- Review of the proportionality of investigative measures.
What does this mean for those affected?
The legal assessment when confronted with an accusation of criminal activity under Section 86a of the German Criminal Code (StGB) often depends less on the mere presence of a symbol than on its meaning in the specific context. However, this context is frequently not considered, or only insufficiently considered, in the early stages of an investigation.
For those affected, the main burden therefore often lies not in a potential conviction, but in the investigation itself. Searches, seizures of mobile phones, analysis of digital communications, or public accusations frequently occur even when the legality of the offense is unclear or doubtful.
In these cases, criminal defense is crucial to clarify from the outset what political statement was actually made, what interpretations are plausible, and why there is no propagandistic or identificatory effect. Early assessment by the defense attorney can prevent a purely formal interpretation of the symbol from becoming entrenched and shaping the further course of the proceedings.
Especially in cases involving Section 86a of the German Criminal Code (StGB), the outcome of proceedings is often decided early on – through proper contextualization, an emphasis on the relevance of fundamental rights, and a consistent limitation of the scope of the investigation. A sound defense therefore aims not only at the alleged offense but also at preventing unnecessary escalation.
FAQ
When does criminal liability arise under Section 86a of the German Criminal Code?
Criminal liability under Section 86a of the German Criminal Code (StGB) may arise if symbols of an unconstitutional or terrorist organization are publicly used or disseminated. The decisive factor is not the subjective motivation, but whether the symbol is perceived by an impartial third party as an identifying mark of such an organization.
Is every slogan automatically a trademark within the meaning of Section 86a of the German Criminal Code?
No. Not every slogan meets the definition of a trademark under Section 86a of the German Criminal Code. Only slogans that are actually used by the respective organization as a symbol of recognition and are objectively capable of expressing identification with it are punishable. Context and specific use are decisive in this regard.
Is a social media post sufficient for criminal liability under Section 86a of the German Criminal Code?
A single post can fulfill the elements of the offense under Section 86a of the German Criminal Code (StGB) if it is publicly accessible and uses or disseminates a symbol. If there is insufficient publicity or if the reach of the post cannot be determined, criminal liability is not automatically established.
Is sharing or forwarding someone else's content punishable under Section 86a of the German Criminal Code?
Merely sharing or forwarding can be considered dissemination within the meaning of Section 86a of the German Criminal Code (StGB). However, criminal liability requires that the content be made publicly accessible and that the accused at least tacitly accepts the dissemination of a prohibited symbol.
What role does intent play in Section 86a of the German Criminal Code?
Section 86a of the German Criminal Code (StGB) is an intentional offense. Accused persons must know, or at least accept, that the symbol used is an emblem of a prohibited or terrorist organization. A lack of intent can preclude criminal liability.
Does freedom of expression apply in the case of Section 86a of the German Criminal Code?
Freedom of expression under Article 5 of the Basic Law must also be considered in the context of Section 86a of the Criminal Code. However, it is superseded if the use of a symbol violates the protective purpose of the norm. Only in cases of clearly recognizable critical or distancing use can socially acceptable use be considered without penalty.
Are private chats or closed groups covered by Section 86a of the German Criminal Code?
Private communication does not automatically fall under Section 86a of the German Criminal Code. Criminal liability only arises if content is effectively passed on to a larger, non-individually defined group of people or if confidentiality is compromised.
What penalties are imposed for a conviction under Section 86a of the German Criminal Code?
Section 86a of the German Criminal Code (StGB) provides for a fine or imprisonment of up to three years. Even a fine can have significant ancillary consequences, for example, regarding weapons, employment, or residency law.
What non-criminal consequences can Section 86a of the German Criminal Code (StGB) have?
In addition to the actual penalty, investigations or convictions under Section 86a of the German Criminal Code (StGB) can lead to measures under weapons law, disciplinary consequences, disadvantages under immigration law, or problems with naturalization procedures.
When should a criminal defense lawyer be consulted in the case of an accusation under Section 86a of the German Criminal Code?
If you are accused of an offense under Section 86a of the German Criminal Code (StGB), you should consult a criminal defense attorney as soon as possible. Early legal advice is crucial to avoid making unwarranted statements, to correctly assess the context, and to keep an eye on potential consequences outside of criminal law.

